![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png)

2012 Many Paths to Tread Tree and Flower Awards
After a number of delays and glitches, the votes have been tallied. Votes were combined from both the polls on LJ at the
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-community.gif)
There are ties, in some case, multiple ties! But we did not plan for tiebreakers, so we will honor those winners equally.
AND THE WINNERS ARE:
RACES:
Favorite story featuring Elves
First Place:
The Army of the North by darthfingon
Hidden Within by Keiliss
Second Place:
Back to the Valley by Thundera Tiger
Third Place:
Winds of Change by curiouswombat
The Green Grave by Ellyn
Abundance by pandemonium_213
Awaiting the Death of the King by Erulisse
Honorable Mention:
Things That May Yet Be, by Marta
The Longest Night by Dawn Felagund
From the Inside by Adonnen Estenniel
Favorite story featuring Men
First Place:
Shadows of Memory by Linda Hoyland
Second Place:
Bedtime Tales of the Sun by Dawn Felagund
Third Place:
Hearts in Stone - Raksha the Demon
Honorable Mention:
The Time for Secrecy by Nath
Favorite story featuring Dwarves
First Place:
Mazarbul by Thundera Tiger
Second Place:
Lake of Fire by Marta
Third Place:
Bones of the Earth (Azaghal), by Marta, (from Marta's Mathoms)
A Rose Among Thorns by Thevina Finduilas
Honorable Mention:
Favorite story featuring Hobbits
First Place:
A New Reckoning by Dreamflower
Yavanna's Gift by Linda Hoyland
Second Place:
Of Shape and Hue and Home by Thundera Tiger
Third Place:
A Dream of Tea Green Silk by Larner 2 1
Honorable Mention:
Pity by Dreamflower
To Absent Friends by Celeritas
Read and Review by Dreamflower, Celeritas
Washed clean by Larner
Favorite story featuring Other races or beings
First Place:
Beneath the Sickle's Swing by Clodia
Second Place:
The Robin's Tale - Lady Branwyn
Third Place:
Of Time and Trees, by Huinare
Awakening by Linda Hoyland
The Burning Cold of Snow, by Erulisse
Honorable Mention:
Caterwauling by Elleth
Entmoot by Pearl Took
TYPES:
Favorite Novel
First Place:
Carefully Taught by Linda
Second Place:
A Little More Conversation by Keiliss
Third Place:
Murder Most Foul by Larner
Honorable Mention:
If Truth be Told - Virtuella
Favorite Drabble or Drabble series
First Place:
Harvest Dreams by Linda Hoyland
Second Place:
A Is For Apple by curiouswombat.
Marking Fours by Raksha the Demon
Duty, Honour, Country by Rhapsody
Third Place:
"The Long Road Home" by curiouswombat
Honorable Mention:
Mightier than the Sword, by Linda Hoyland (in Hues of Middle-earth
Gandalf Observes Boromir, by Dreamflower
Favorite Fixed-Length-Ficlet, other than drabble
First Place:
Fire and Ice, by Linda Hoyland
Second Place:
Heart of Glass by Raksha The Demon
Letters in the Sand by Rhapsody
Third Place:
Reflections, by Adonnen Estenniel
Just Right by Dana
Honorable Mention:
Rite of Spring by Raksha the Demon
Favorite Poem
First Place:
Tears for the Fallen by pandemonium_213
Second Place:
Upon Meeting Arwen-Voices of Middle-earth by Armariel
Sleep Easy by Shireling
Third Place:
Ice Maiden by Shireling
Quietly by Pearl Took
Honorable Mention:
Utumno to Valimar by Huinare
Favorite Nonfiction, essay
First Place:
A Woman in Few Words: The Character of Nerdanel and Her Treatment in Canon and Fandom by Dawn Felagund
Second Place:
Characterization in Fanfic: Using Canon as the DNA for Your Characters by Dreamflower
Third Place:
A Man of Quality: Faramir, Captain of Gondor by Antane
Honorable Mention:
Aragorn: a Feminist's Nightmare? By Virtuella
The Myth of the One Ring's Power by Dreamflower
Favorite Nonfiction, research
First Place:
Hobbit Names and Naming Conventions by Dreamflower
Second Place:
That Guy Who Carries the Banner by Nath
Favorite Art, traditional
First Place:
And Maedhros Stood Aside by Erulisse
Second Place:
Deep in the Forest by Linda Hoyland
Crickhollow at Twilight by Dreamflower
Third Place:
I Espy With My Great Eye by pandemonium_213
Favorite Art, photomanip
First Place:
Rauros by Elleth
Second Place:
Artwork for "Dust" by Ellyn
Tilion's Chase by Rhapsody
Third Place:
Minas Tirith by Ellyn
Favorite Work-in-Progress
First Place:
The Princess and the Horse Lord by Oshun
Second Place:
The Prisoner and the Hobbit by pandemonium_213 and Dreamflower
Third Place:
Lords of Gondor by Linaewen
Honorable Mention:
Istari: circa 1040 Third Age by Huinare
Quest by Cathleen
Favorite Vignette
First Place:
A Crash Course in History by Himring
Second Place:
Renewal by Linda Hoyland
Hithlain by Himring
Third Place:
Born Again (in Through the Eyes of Maia and Wizard) by Larner
Clouds Will Clear Again by Elleth
Honorable Mention:
Ranger's Dawn by Raksha the Demon
SOURCE:
Favorite Story set in The Silmarillion
First Place:
Season of Hope by Keiliss
Second Place:
The Silmarillion Gospel by Araloth the Random
Two Small Pieces of Glass by Ellyn
Third Place:
Noldolante by Dawn Felagund
Honorable Mention:
Broken by Keiliss
Wind Song by Erulisse
Favorite Story set during The Hobbit
First Place:
A Case of Silver Spoons by Elleth
Second Place:
Winged Release by FoxRafer
Third Place:
The Jay and the Moon: Things They Didn't Tell You in the Red Book by Huinare
At the Last It Biteth by mercuriewords
Favorite Story set during LotR
First Place:
The White Tree by Linda Hoyland
Second Place:
Eight Elven Cloaks by Virtuella
Third Place:
Bachelors by Zhie
Honorable Mention:
Day's Ending by Raksha the Demon
Favorite post-LotR story
First Place:
A Time to Reap by Linda Hoyland
Dust by curiouswombat
Second Place:
Halbarad's Last Journey by Ellyn
Passover and Pilgrimage by Larner
Third Place:
Living Jewels by Shirebound
Mr. Frodo's Waiting by Linaewen
Honorable Mention:
The King's Time by Larner
Favorite Story inspired by other books by Tolkien
First Place:
Indignation by Zhie
Second Place:
Western Duty, Eastern Desire by Adonnen Estenniel
Favorite story set in The Lord of the Rings movies by Peter Jackson
First Place:
Can You Sing, Master Hobbit? By Shirebound
Second Place:
There's Always Hope by Elleyn
Third Place:
At the Black Gate by Shirebound
Honorable Mention:
Marian's Wish by Linaewen
GENRES:
Favorite Humor story
First Place:
Miss Dora Baggins' Book of Manners: Or The Shire Hobbit's Guide to Proper Behavior for Every Occasion by Dreamflower
Second Place:
Avar an Away by ignoblebard
Third Place:
Smoke Gets In Your Eyes by Linda Hoyland
Honorable Mention:
Ladies' Guide to Middle-earth's Eligible Bachelors, by Virtuella
Favorite Romance story
First Place:
Horse Talk by Oshun
Second Place:
In Need of a Wife by Linda Hoyland
Third Place:
Better Once Than Never by Celeritas
Honorable Mention:
Seal Upon Thy Heart by Linda Hoyland
Peregrin and Diamond by Pearl Took
Favorite Adventure story
First Place:
Trotter by Dreamflower
Second Place:
A Mirkwood Solstice by Thundera Tiger
Third Place:Where No Birds Sing by Linda Hoyland
Honorable Mention:Thoughts of a Dagger by Virodeil
Favorite Drama
First Place: The Day of the Dragon by Keiliss
Second Place:The Heirloom by Keiliss
Third Place:
We Shall Stand by Alma Heart
Song of Hope by Linda Hoyland
Pippin's Crucible by Pearl Took
Honorable Mention:
Beneath the Midsummer Moon by Linda Hoyland
The Elysian Fields by Marchwriter
In the Darkness of the Moon by Erulisse
Favorite Crack!Fic
First Place: FINDUILEORN SUNDERED!, in: A crack and the staff split asunder by Huinare
Second Place:The Job Interview by Larner
Third Place:Mushroom Tales by Nath
Honorable Mention:In Dwimordene, In Lorien by Kaylee Arafinwiel
Favorite AU story
First Place:
Vairë Was a Weaver, or, Real Men Wear Corsets (a farce) by Celeritas
Second Place:
At the Turn of the Tide by Raksha the Demon
Things That Have Not Yet Come to Pass by Levade
Third Place:
Transformation by Larner
Evil Undone by Virtuella
The White Ladies of Eryn Carantaur by ningloreth
Honorable Mention:
Púkelwoman by Virtuella
Favorite Crossover story
First Place:
Ships That Pass in The Night by Thranduil Oropherion Redux
Second Place:
Walking Down Narrow Streets by Marta
Hastaina by Dawn Felagund
Third Place:
Red Fell the Dew in Rammas Echor by San Antonio Rose
Honorable Mention:
A Month of Sundays by KarasAunty
Favorite Gapfiller
First Place:
The Unwillingby Thundera Tiger
Through the Dimrill Gate by Nath
Second Place:
Ranger,Ringbearer and Resolutionby Linda Hoyland
Third Place:
The One by Linda Hoyland and Raksha the Demon
Honorable Mention:
One Breath of Air by Celeritas
Favorite Fluff
First Place:
Down the Withywindle by Clodia
Second Place:
Hunting the Dragon by Linda Hoyland
Third Place:
Yew by Pearl Took
Honorable Mention:
Under the Lilac Bush by Dreamflower
Favorite Family story
First Place:
One Bright Star by Levade
Second Place:
Lingering Shadows by Linda Hoyland
In the Town Called Acceptance by Dawn Felagund
Third Place:
Concerning the Matter of Tom Took by Pearl Took
Honorable Mention:
Seeing Stars Raksha The Demon
Favorite Recipe!fic
First Place:
The Taste of Strawberries by Dreamflower
Second Place:
No Skills In The Kitchen by Libbstarz
Third Place:
Sharing Dinner on Lobelia Lane by Pearl Took
Honorable Mention:
Of Bread and Butter by Cathleen
CHARACTERS:
Favorite characterization of Aragorn
First Place:
A Lesson in Operative Technique by SurgicalSteel
Second Place:
The Light Bearer by Linda Hoyland
Third Place:
The Healer's Journey by Linda Hoyland
Invocation Of Memory by curiouswombat
Gone Fishing by Linda Hoyland
Turtles All the Way Down by Marta
Honorable Mention:
Acrostic by Virtuella
The Blue Hour Over Ered Luin by FoxRafer
Mask of Virtue by Linda Hoyland
Favorite characterization of Arwen
First Place:
Manners Maketh Man by Linda Hoyland
In the Depths of Winter by Marta
Second Place:
Beauty Is In the Eye of the Beholder by Linda Hoyland
Third Place:
While the Candles Burn by Virtuella
Watching from afarby Nath
Honorable Mention:
Envinyale by Nath
Favorite characterization of Bilbo
First Place:
A Place for Gandalf by Dreamflower
Second Place:
Not all gold? by Nath
Escaping by the Dozen by Thundera Tiger
Third Place:
The Diary by Pearl Took
Honorable Mention:
His Wealth Shall Flow in Fountains by Celeritas
Favorite characterization of Boromir
First Place:
In Empty Lands by Larner
Second Place:
Rest and Recreation by Raksha the Demon
Third Place:
The Slave of the Ring by Linda Hoyland
Honorable Mention:
The World Ahead by Linaewen
Favorite characterization of Denethor
First Place:
The Eagle's Gift by Raksha the Demon
Second Place:
Kingdom of Ashes by Linda Hoyland
Third Place:
Hope Stirs by Linaewen
Honorable Mention:
A Wish for Yestare by Rhyselle
Favorite characterization of Elrond
First Place:
Driftwood by pandemonium_213
Second Place:
A Walk in the Forest, an Evening by the Fire by Himring
Third Place:
A Fool's Hope by Thundera Tiger
Honorable Mention:
Droplets by Dawn Felagund
Favorite characterization of Éomer
First Place:
Éomer's Guide to Contemporary Bardic Works by curiouswombat
Second Place:
Some Like It Hot by Virtuella
Third Place:
Remembrance by Rhyselle
Honorable Mention:
The Course of Defeat by Adonnen Estenniel
Favorite characterization of Éowyn
First Place:
Worse Than the Witch-King by Virtuella
Edoras to Ithilien…in Twelve Moves by curiouswombat
Second Place:
Spring's First Thaw by Marta
When Winter First Begins to Bite by Marta
Legend by Raksha the Demon
Favorite characterization of Faramir
First Place:
Fey by Thundera Tiger
Second Place:
Heart of the Storm by Raksha the Demon
Third Place:
Catastrophe by Linda Hoyland
Honorable Mention:
New Roads and Secret Gates by Larner
The good will of all good men by Nath
Favorite characterization of Fëanor
First Place:
A Gift for a King by Dawn Felagund
Second Place:
For What I Wait by Dawn Felagund
Essecarme by Dawn Felagund
Favorite characterization of Frodo
First Place:
All Things Were Now Made Ready… by Dreamflower
Second Place:
Of Cakes and Crumbs and Distant Dreams by Lindelea
Third Place:
Decorum by Larner
Honorable Mention:
Second Mum by Larner
Favorite characterization of Galadriel
First Place:
Footsteps in Time by Keiliss
Second Place:
Stranger at the Gates by Linda Hoyland
Third Place:
Passing Grace by Virtuella
Honorable Mention:
The Light That Binds Them by Adonnen Estenniel
The Lady's Gift by Dreamflower
Favorite characterization of Gandalf
First Place:
Looking for Dragons by Raksha the Demon
Second Place:
A Sign of Hope by Linda Hoyland
Third Place:
Thoughts of the Servant of the Secret Flame by Larner
Honorable Mention:
Hoarded History by Linaewen
Favorite characterization of Gimli
First Place:
Of Rowan and Ruin by Thundera Tiger
Second Place:
Holiday by Nath
Too Young by Linaewen
Third Place:
Fissures by Thundera Tiger
The Soil of the Shire is Deep by Celeritas
Favorite characterization of Glorfindel
First Place:
Flame of the Desert by pandemonium_213
Second Place:
Gofi and the Balrog by Levade
Third Place:
Broken and Burnt by Peregrin Ionad
Honorable Mention:
Red Herring by pandemonium_213
Favorite characterization of Halbarad
First Place:
The King's Surgeon: the Happy AU by SurgicalSteel
Second Place:
The Gift of Foresight by Linda Hoyland
Third Place:
The Summons by Marta
Honorable Mention:
In the Name of the King by Ellyn
Favorite characterization of Legolas
First Place:
Stray but a little… by Thundera Tiger
Second Place:
Leaf Subsides to Leaf by Ignoblebard
Third Place:
Knew I Love Once? by Thranduil Oropherion Redux
Honorable Mention:
Gifts from the Black Gates by Erulisse
Favorite characterization of Maedhros
First Place:
White Nights, in Through Sorrow to Find Joy by Dawn Felagund
Second Place:
Flying Free by Keiliss
Third Place:
For the Want of a Hand by Rhyselle
Favorite characterization of Maglor
First Place:
Homeward Bound by Keiliss
Second Place:
Once Upon Amon Hen by Rhapsody
Third Place:
Oaths Forsworn by Rhapsody
Favorite characterization of Merry
First Place:
Inner Light by pandemonium_213
Second Place:
Good King Elessar by Dreamflower
Third Place:
Annals of the West by Dreamflower
Honorable Mention:
As Close As by Dana
Merry and Blackie's Wonderful Day by Pearl Took
Favorite characterization of Pippin
First Place:
The Elven Way by Linda Hoyland
Second Place:
The Dare by Dreamflower
Third Place:
A Time to Reap by Cathleen
Honorable Mention:
Yule Tails by Pearl Took
Favorite characterization of Sam
First Place:
Praiseworthy by Thundera Tiger
Second Place:
Sam the Turtle Goes to Mordor by Dreamflower
Third Place:
Fighting Dragons by Larner
Honorable Mention:
A Moment's Peace by Pearl Took
Slipped Under the Door of the Master Bedroom, September 25, 1444 by Celeritas
Favorite characterization of Saruman
First Place:
Saruman's Housewarming Party by Huinare
Second Place:
The Tower of the Cunning Mind by Larner
Favorite characterization of Sauron
First Place:
The Tower by Raksha the Demon
Second Place:
Non-violent communication in Barad-Dur, in: A crack and the staff split asunder:
Crackfic and General Wackiness by Huinare
Third Place:
Jerusalem, Jerusalem - for Kaylee Arafinwiel by Celeritas
Honorable Mention:
Coveting the Light by Larner
Favorite characterization of Theoden
May It Be a Light To You In Dark Places by Cathleen 12 2
By Pastures Green, by curiouswombat (in "Under the Rainbow") 8 1
Favorite characterization of Theoden
First Place:
May It Be a Light To You In Dark Places by Cathleen
Second Place:
By Pastures Green (in "Under the Rainbow" by curiouswombat
Favorite characterization of Thorin
First Place:
Questing by Thundera Tiger
Second Place:
The Return of the Kingdom: A Journey through Arda by Larner
Favorite characterization of a member of the House of Finwë
First Place:
After Rain by Himring
Second Place:
The Craft of the Elven Smith by Larner
Third Place:
Tales from the Other Side—It's Not All About War--Summertime by Erulisse
Father and Son by Adlanth
Favorite characterization of a resident of Doriath
First Place:
The Long Road Home by curiouswombat
Second Place:
Forth to War by Dawn Felagund
Third Place:
Mercy Found in Betrayal by Kaylee Arafinwiel
Favorite characterization of a member of the Ainur
First Place:
If Ever a Fruit Ripens by Pearl Took
Not All Who Wander are Lost by Kaylee Arafiniel
Second Place:
Variation on a Theme by Eru by Rhyselle
The Hidden Lady by Rhapsody
Third Place:
In Defence of Vána, the Ever-Young by Himring
Honorable Mention:
The Omen by Ellyn
Favorite characterization of a Numenorean
First Place:
The Far Side of the World by SurgicalSteel
Second Place:
Grace and Memory by Larner
Full of Wisdom and Perfect in Beauty by dracoena
Tower of the Moon by Nath
Third Place:
Spindrift by Nath
Honorable Mention:
Fire and Smoke by Marta
Favorite Story featuring an Original Character
First Place:
A Surgeon in the Making by SurgicalSteel
Second Place:
No Traveler Returns by Ignoble Bard
Third Place:
Voice in the Night by Linda Hoyland
Honorable Mention:
The Measure of a Man by Virtuella
Uncle Teo's Fiddle by Cathleen
First Place:
Lalme, Alalme by Himring
Second Place:
Shelter from the Storm by Linda Hoyland
Third Place:
A Golden Flower by Celeritas
How I Wish by Dawn Felagund
Not One But Two by Linda Hoyland
Honorable Mention:
A Proper Man for Summer by Linda Hoyland
Becoming by Nath
Healing in the Halls of Mandos by Pearl Took
SPECIAL CATEGORIES:
Favorite story by a new author (author a member of MPTT for six months or less)
First Place:
And All Our Wounds Forgiven by Marchwriter
Second Place:
The Music of Her Life by Wtiger5
Third Place:
Cormallen by the_mad_hobbit
Favorite Illustration of a story by an artist
Art for Larner's 'Murder Most Foul' by Citrine2 4 1
The Gate to Everywhere--artwork by Armariel 4
A Gallery of Pictures for "If You Could See What I Hear", (by Cathleen) by Paul Ferendzo 4 1
Favorite Illustration of a story by an artist
First Place:
Art for Larner's 'Murder Most Foul' by Citrine2
Second Place:
The Gate to Everywhere--artwork by Armariel
A Gallery of Pictures for "If You Could See What I Hear", (by Cathleen) by Paul Ferendzo
We would like to congratulate all of the winners, and to thank all the voters and nominators for helping us to get this first Tree & Flower Awards off the ground! We had a few hitches along the way, but I think we learned a lot!
There will be some lovely banners made by our intrepid banner-making volunteers available at the Many Paths to Tread archive by the end of the week! Thank you very much to Ellyn and to Nath for all their hard work, and to our intrepid webmistress Dawn Felagund for getting them up!
no subject
Date: 2012-09-25 07:18 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2012-09-25 07:28 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2012-09-25 07:35 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2012-09-26 01:59 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2012-09-25 07:37 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2012-09-25 07:39 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2012-09-25 08:25 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2012-09-26 01:58 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2012-09-25 08:14 pm (UTC)Thanks too, to everyone who voted - not just for my works, but generally - without the voters there can be no value to the awards!
no subject
Date: 2012-09-26 01:57 pm (UTC)And you are right--I'm so glad that people participated and voted, and hope even more people will vote next year!
And of course, it's not over yet--keep your eyes open for the Overall Winners poll.
no subject
Date: 2012-09-25 08:36 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2012-09-26 01:47 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2012-09-25 08:58 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2012-09-26 01:47 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2012-09-25 09:46 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2012-09-26 01:45 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2012-09-25 10:45 pm (UTC)On the other hand, I'm happy to have had the opportunity to participate and I found some great new stories to read! And of course, it's always sweet to discover that other people like my stories enough to vote for them. I'm very pleased about the ones that placed!
Thanks for all the hard work that went into this, we should definitely do this again!
no subject
Date: 2012-09-26 01:44 pm (UTC)And there were some awesome stories nominated!
no subject
Date: 2012-09-25 11:19 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2012-09-26 01:41 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2012-09-26 04:16 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2012-09-26 01:40 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2012-09-26 02:38 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2012-09-26 02:15 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2012-09-26 02:45 pm (UTC)On the banners: I only had two entries, so it looked to me that there were dozens and dozens of banners, but one of mine was not there! I have been kind of dopey this week. Hectic.
no subject
Date: 2012-09-26 03:09 pm (UTC)I really want to... but I just can't now. *sighs*
I have been kind of dopey this week. Hectic.
Here as well, these days I am just glad to curl up on the couch once the kids are asleep..
no subject
Date: 2012-09-26 02:19 pm (UTC)Thank you all
*runs off with her shineys like a proper Maglor fangurl and no I do not live nearby water so no worries LOL*
My mind is blown.
Date: 2012-09-26 09:01 pm (UTC)Re: My mind is blown.
Date: 2012-09-26 09:48 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2012-09-28 09:03 pm (UTC)(On another note, I notice that one of my stories on the list is a crack-fic...My very first MEFA award was for a crack-fic too. Are people trying to tell me I should write more of it? LOL!)
Kaylee Arafinwiel
no subject
Date: 2012-10-03 12:32 am (UTC)And thanks to Dreamflower and all for setting this up in the first place! *more hugs*
Namarie, God bless, Antane :)